Cole Hutson
Cole Hutson is a 20-year-old rookie defenseman who is in Washington's bottom defensive pair as of the Nov. 1 game, with a possible power-play role that I could not confirm.
Role
Beat writer Sammi Silber's lines for the Nov. 1 game against Minnesota, as relayed by the NHL Game Day Lines account (checked Nov. 2), had Hutson on the third pair with Jack St. Ivany. The pairs above them were Chychrun-Roy and Fehervary-Liljegren. The same pairing appeared on Oct. 31. In the Oct. 26 post, St. Ivany does not appear and McIlrath skates with Chychrun. A practice report in the same feed had Hutson with McIlrath, and an earlier one had him with Desharnais, so his partner has changed several times. The Morning Puck line page lists Hutson among the power-play names for Nov. 1, but its format does not show which unit he is on or whether he is on the ice for it. Daily Faceoff's own line page returned only a stale 2025 snapshot when I fetched it, so I am not reporting what it says. I found no reported ice-time figures. Sandin and McIlrath were listed in the pre-Minnesota lines as healthy extras, so they compete for the same spot.
He is a left-shot defenseman with a strong offensive reputation: two seasons of college scoring at Boston University and a Tim Taylor Award as national rookie of the year. Washington's GM said earlier this year he could turn heads. A Russian Machine Never Breaks primer argued his role should grow because few defensemen are signed beyond this season. He has already held an NHL spot into November, and he appears in a power-play listing on Morning Puck.
He is on the third pair, behind Chychrun, Roy, Fehervary and Liljegren. The defense is deep, and his partner has changed repeatedly, which points to a role that is not yet settled. I found nothing confirming a first-unit power-play spot, and the forward group around him is deep. He is 20 and listed at 180 pounds. His 2025-26 sample was 13 games, 8 points and 249 minutes of ice time, which is small.
Where analysts split
The open question is whether he moves up from the third pair to a bigger role, specifically power-play time, or stays in a sheltered bottom-pair job. I found no analyst piece arguing either side in detail this season, only lineup reports.
Research confidence: thin. Outlooks are grounded in web search over current reporting and refreshed through the season.
Others at D
Fantasy Memo reads your league and answers that every Monday, and checks your lineup on the days you play.
Connect your league: 14 days free