FantasyMemo
Player outlooks · D · CAR

Shayne Gostisbehere

Consensus #86 · D10 · tier 7Week 5: 3 gamesUpdated Nov 2

Gostisbehere is a third-pair left defenseman who runs the first power-play unit, so his value this season comes almost entirely from power-play time.

Role

Third pair at even strength with Juuso Valimaki on the right. This comes from the Nov. 1 projected lines, which Inside the Rink, Yahoo and Sportsbetting Dime all carried, and from ESPN's line page (about 8 days old). Behind Slavin-Chatfield and Miller-Walker. PP1 per ESPN and 5V5 Hockey (Oct. 29): Gostisbehere as the lone defenseman with Ehlers, Aho, Svechnikov and Blake. Beat writer Ryan Henkel's PP1 grouping, as relayed by GameDayTweets, matches. Mike Reilly was his partner in mid-October and is now listed among the roster's defensemen, but he is not in the Nov. 1 projected lineup. I could not fetch a current Daily Faceoff page, so I have no current ice-time figures for him. Last season he had 6 power-play points among his 11 points in 16 games.

The case for

He holds the PP1 quarterback spot on a power play that Sportsbetting Dime put at 22.6% as of Nov. 1. Last season's line (16 GP, 11 points, 6 of them on the power play) shows how much of his production comes from that unit. Nothing in the sources I read shows another defenseman threatening that job.

The case against

At even strength he is on the third pair, and last season's line shows only 28 shots, 8 hits and 10 blocks in 16 games. That leaves little production outside the power play. PP2 lists vary by source (Valimaki, Miller or Stankoven in different outlets), so the unit is not fully settled. If the top unit is reshuffled or Carolina draws fewer penalties, his output would drop.

Where analysts split

broad agreement

Research confidence: reported. Outlooks are grounded in web search over current reporting and refreshed through the season.

Others at D

Every hockey outlook

Should Shayne be in your lineup tonight?

Fantasy Memo reads your league and answers that every Monday, and checks your lineup on the days you play.

Connect your league: 14 days free
The Memo by email · free

One memo for every manager, in the sports you play.

Every Monday from opening night: the week's streams, the goalie starts, the swing categories, the adds worth making and the ones to skip, for every manager, not just yours. Add football or basketball if you play them.

Your own league gets its own memo in the app. This one is for everyone.