Carnell Tate
A No. 4 overall rookie handed a starting perimeter job in a rebuilt Titans offense — the talent and draft capital point to real volume, but the on-field production hasn't arrived yet and the coverage I found is still from the opening stretch of the season rather than a settled mid-season sample.
Role
Projected full-time outside receiver with the first-team offense under Robert Saleh's staff, working as one of Cam Ward's primary targets. He played 35-38 snaps across the preseason, virtually all with the starters, and drew six targets in three exhibitions (zero catches). Competition for looks comes from Calvin Ridley on the boundary, the slot/complementary bodies (Ayomanor, Dike type roles), tight end Chig Okonkwo, and the backfield's checkdown share. Nothing in reporting suggests he is being rotated or held to a package — the Titans drafted him to be a every-down starter and have talked about him that way since OTAs.
Fourth overall picks at receiver get force-fed, and Tate is a polished, ready-made route runner rather than a project — he led the rookie class in yards per target (13.1 in 2025, 11.6 for his career) and ranked third in yards per route run at Ohio State. He turned heads from OTAs through minicamp, has held first-team reps all summer, and is attached to a young quarterback the team is building around. If the efficiency travels, the target share follows quickly.
He caught nothing on six preseason targets, and his college profile is high-floor rather than alpha — he never carried a huge volume share at Ohio State even as the best receiver on the field. The Titans' offense has been one of the league's least productive, the receivers coach publicly challenged him to play with more physicality, and a rookie who isn't winning contested reps on a bad offense can be a low-efficiency, boom-or-nothing weekly play regardless of snap count.
Where analysts split
Whether the blank preseason is meaningless noise or an early sign that Tate's finesse, catch-point game needs time against NFL press — i.e., does the target volume that comes with the No. 4 pick convert into production now, or in the second half of the year? Everyone agrees on the role; the split is on the timeline.
Research confidence: reported. Outlooks are grounded in web search over current reporting and refreshed through the season.
Fantasy Memo reads your league and answers that every Tuesday — and checks again before kickoff.
Connect your league — 14 days free