Jonathan Taylor
Taylor is the Colts' lead back and the center of their offense. Through six games his volume and touchdowns have been steady, but his efficiency has been poor on a 2-4 team.
Role
He is the clear workhorse. ESPN's game log shows his carries in the last five games as 24, 23, 20, 15 and 21, plus 15 catches on the season. In the Titans game he had 25 touches (21 carries, 4 targets, 2 catches). I did not find a snap share, a target share or a named backup in current reporting, and I did not read a depth chart, so I can't say who competes for his work.
Optimists point to the volume and the scoring. ESPN's season line is 122 carries for 492 yards and 7 rushing touchdowns. CBS/RotoWire notes he is on pace for double-digit touchdowns again. His 151 scrimmage yards against Tennessee were a season high, with a 38-yard catch. SI's Colts site called his play "individual brilliance" despite the weak surroundings.
Skeptics point to efficiency and game script. RotoWire noted his 4.0 yards per carry would be the worst of his career, and he has fallen just short of 100 rushing yards in four of six games. He has two lost fumbles this season, and the Titans fumble set up a short field. The team is 2-4 after blowing a 13-0 halftime lead (Newsweek), and Daniel Jones threw two interceptions in that game. Offensive struggles can limit scoring chances.
Where analysts split
Broad agreement on his role. The coverage I found treats his workload as secure and doesn't dispute it. The only open question is whether the offense around him improves enough to lift his 4.0 yards per carry and his scoring chances. I found no analyst split on that, only the general concern about the offense.
Research confidence: thin. Outlooks are grounded in web search over current reporting and refreshed through the season.
Others at RB
Fantasy Memo reads your league and answers that every Tuesday, and checks again before kickoff.
Connect your league: 14 days free